the arrest of professor Gates has blown way up, even to the point of clouding the news of health care reform -- which the insurance companies must love. i was pretty surprised that a local incident got a mention from the president -- and even more surprised by his choice of words.
(as an aside: isn't it funny that while the word "legalization" is not in the president's vocabulary, "stupidly" is? i guess maybe the first intellectual president of the last decade doesn't have five syllable capacity in his vocab).
charges of racism are flying around, and cambridge is backing their officer, who appears to have a pretty good community record, particularly regarding race. it could be that he's a racist, it could be that he's not. it could be that Gates is the racist. all of this misses the larger picture, which is totally independent of race: a man was arrested in his own (proven) home, after asking the police to leave, apparently on the charge of mouthing off.
reporters bloviate hundreds of words about the arrest, including quotes from police at all levels claiming that no misconduct occurred, and yet no mention is made of the disorderly conduct for which Gates was handcuffed in his own house.
Obama comes close to raising the issue: "I think it was a pretty straightforward commentary that you probably don't need to handcuff a guy, a middle-aged man who uses a cane, who's in his own home". But the president clouds the issue by throwing in descriptions of the man. The simple fact is that it's outrageous that the cops can come into my home, when i'm all alone, and arrest me for harming their sanctimonious ears.
it makes no difference whether a man in his own home -- alone, unarmed, presenting no danger to his neighbors -- asks the police politely or rudely to leave. once asked to leave, if there's no actual crime being comitted, the police should leave.
this is pretty fucking clear, i think:
The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated.
People have a right to be secure in their houses. Saying "fuck off" is not a crime, even if it's said to a police officer, even if he's got a long and distinguished record.
Everyone throwing around race in this issue is doing a disservice to the American people -- who are not secure in their houses from unreasonable arrest.
An American demanded an unwelcome visitor to leave his house, and was hauled off to jail for the words he used in so doing. That's a disgrace.
